Informed Consent: Balancing Efficiency and Ethics
Lessons from FairTalk #12
FairTalk #12, 3rd September 2024
In our latest edition of FairTalk, we discussed about the delicate balance between efficiency and ethics in informed consent. The conversation, enriched by record attendance of our community and diverse insights, brought together a range of voices to explore how to responsibly gather content while upholding ethical standards. Informed consent is a cornerstone of ethical storytelling, but how do we make it efficient without sacrificing integrity? This was the core question that guided our discussions.
Panelists:
- Kari Brayman, Senior Content Manager at Vitamin Angels
- Shazia Islamshah: Senior Advisor at Swiss Center of Competence for International Cooperation
- Selvaprakash Lakshmanan, Visual Creator at Fairpicture, India
- Josemarie Nyagah, Visual Creator at Fairpicture, Kenya
Moderator: Aurel Vogel, Co-founder at Fairpicture
The Ethical Imperative of Informed Consent
During FairTalk #12, our speakers emphasised that balancing the drive for efficient content creation with the imperative for ethical practice requires empathy, transparency, and a genuine understanding of the cultural contexts in which we operate.
Photo: Abdul Raafi Mohammed
True respect starts with informed consent.
Informed consent goes far beyond simply obtaining permission. It’s about creating a space where individuals feel empowered to share their stories — or not — in a way that respects their autonomy.
Addressing Power Dynamics in Content Creation
One of the key themes was understanding power dynamics in visual storytelling. Shazia and others highlighted the often unseen complexities that arise when capturing images and narratives, particularly in communities that may not be accustomed to being in front of a lens.
Acknowledging these dynamics means prioritising empathy over efficiency, making sure that those involved are truly comfortable with how their images and stories will be used. This often means slowing down, taking time to build trust, and being clear about intentions.
Practical Approaches for Ethical Content Collection
Kari shared a thoughtful approach to content collection, focusing on equitable standards. She uses a printed booklet to explain to participants how their images or stories will be used, ensuring clarity and authentic representation. This seemingly simple step is a powerful way to bridge the gap between ethical intent and practical implementation, making sure that consent is both informed and freely given.
Meanwhile, Aurel and Josemarie discussed innovative strategies for obtaining consent, even in unpredictable environments where direct communication can be challenging. Visual tools like the Fair Consent app can facilitate understanding, helping participants grasp what they are agreeing to without ambiguity. It’s an example of technology being used not just to streamline the process, but to enhance the ethical quality of the interaction.
FairConsent App v1.5, by Fairpicture
Efficiency Meets Ethics: A Practical Toolkit
Efficiency in obtaining informed consent doesn’t have to mean compromising on ethics. It’s about creating systems and tools that support ethical interactions at scale. This is where Fairpicture’s FairConsent app comes in, designed to make obtaining informed consent both simple and meaningful.
New! FairConsent for Teams
We’re excited to announce that a new version of FairConsent, specifically for teams and organisations, is coming soon!
This version will be tailored to help streamline global productions while ensuring ethical standards are upheld.
Join the waitlist now to receive early access and personalized support.
Watch the full recording of FairTalk #12 on balancing ethics and efficiency in informed consent collection.
Held on September 3rd, 2024, it saw record attendance and engagement, reflecting the growing interest in ethical practices across organisations. This momentum inspires our efforts towards a fairer and more ethical visual representation of our world.
Moving Forward Together
Our discussion in FairTalk #12 underscored that the path toward ethical content creation is a collective one. By sharing practical strategies, tools, and insights, we are building an ecosystem that values authenticity and respect over mere speed and quantity.
Let’s keep the conversation going and continue to evolve how we tell stories: responsibly, ethically, and with the full consent of those we feature.
Connect with us via LinkedIn and subscribe to our newsletter to join the community.
More from our blog
October 2022 - Jörg Arnold
Visual Communication on a Tight Budget
Why do so many communication, marketing and fundraising managers struggle to find budget for photography and video production, and why do we need to solve this?
Learn more about Visual Communication on a Tight Budget
November 2023 - N'Deane Helajzen
Navigating Generative AI in Ethical Visual Communication: Opportunities, Challenges, and the Role of Authenticity
Discover how AI reshapes creative storytelling and faces ethical hurdles in our latest post.
Learn more about Navigating Generative AI in Ethical Visual Communication: Opportunities, Challenges, and the Role of Authenticity
September 2021 - Jörg Arnold
The moment of photography
We asked ourselves: For how long beyond the momentum of photography is it ethical for NGOs to use images for their communication? Jörg Arnold reflects in this blog.
Learn more about The moment of photography