Informed consent – The right to one’s own image

Jörg Arnold by Jörg Arnold, October 2021

Who doesn’t know the shyness of photographing strangers in their everyday lives. For example the fishwives at the market in Chisinau, Moldova, selling their live carp. Or the grandmother in Lobalong, South Sudan, smoking her pipe with pleasure. And then it is us with our camera. We feel that we are crossing a line when we point our lens at the picturesque subjects and press the shutter. 

On the other hand: Who doesn’t know the annoyance of being recognised as a local and photographed without being asked by some tourist on the street or at the market? And who doesn’t know the shame of looking at a picture that shows oneself? When the hair is in the wrong position, the nose is too big, the shirt is fitting badly.

210116_DiakonieKH_Guatemala_Fairpicture_075

Photo: Sandra Sebastian/Diakonie Katastrophenhilfe/Fairpicture

The right to one's own image

“I don’t want you to take my picture.”—The denunciation of a hitherto unquestionable consent may be hard to digest for the father of a pubescent daughter. But it is the honest expression of what the “right to one’s own image” means. Legally, it is a narrower or broader personal right. A right that can be sued for. In Germany, for example, “anyone who unauthorisedly produces or transmits a picture that shows the helplessness of another person and thereby violates the highly personal sphere of life of the person depicted is liable to a prison sentence of up to two years.”

quote icon

The right to one's image is right that can be sued for.

Jörg Arnold

Fairpicture

Concordia_Tranzit_26.01.2021_Prizren-53

21 January 2021: The family of Arben Mustafa (39) and Sevdije Mustafa (40) in Prizren, Kosovo. Their 13-year-old daughter Xhulieta attends Concordia Tranzit's music school.
Photo: Samir Karahoda/Concordia/Fairpicture

A question of power

But where there is no plaintiff, there is no judge. And the greater the physical and social distance, the less the rights and personal integrity of the people depicted count. Earthquake victims find themselves unawares as illustrators of stories that do not correspond to the realities of their lives, provided with statements that they never made in this way. “Do No Harm”, “Human Rights-Based Approach”—principles that apply to the programme work of development organisations and to the actions of multinational corporations must also apply to fundraising and communication: People who are willing to make their face, their person and their life situation public are not paid models who sell themselves to advertising. These people have rights they do not have to ask for. They decide how much of themselves they want to reveal and whether the Sunday shirt fits their poverty.

FairConsent app

Learn more

Streamline your informed consent collection in photo and video productions - paper free and ethically thanks to 20+ languages, audio consents and photo confirmation options.

Get it for iOS
quote icon

The people depicted usually decide whether and in what form an image may be taken and published. For this reason, photos may usually only be published if those depicted in them have given their consent.

Swiss Data Protection Commissioner

The right to informed consent

Rights are not just protections. They also define entitlements. The Swiss Data Protection Commissioner, for example, has a clear opinion on what this means in relation to the “right to one’s own image”. Namely, “the people depicted usually decide whether and in what form an image may be taken and published. For this reason, photos may usually only be published if those depicted in them have given their consent.” 

Obtaining informed consent is not just an annoying formality that can be done on the side. It is about explaining the context to the people depicted, informing them of what will happen to their images and telling them that they do not have to make themselves available if they do not want to. This is a challenging task for the photographers and video journalists. They need not only social skills for it, but also time—time that has to be made available to them by the clients and that is paid for.

DRC_Cox_200823_XYZ6345_copy

23 August 2020. Nurul Amin's daughter Mubarika stands in front of the door and looks outside. She says: “Our school is closed. We have to stay inside all day. We can't go outside to play because of the virus.” 
Photo: Mohammad Rakibul Hasan/Danish Refugee Council/Fairpicture

Not only a question of respect

War, disaster events: There are few situations in which obtaining informed consent is not possible. And the excuse that those photographed have no idea what happens to their picture anyway is just as discriminatory and belittling as the attitude that the willingness to be photographed is something like a quid pro quo for help rendered. It is not about knowledge and gratitude, but about respect, fairness and justice. There is no reason not to ask someone if he or she may be photographed or filmed (for example with the FairConsent app). And there is no reason to assume any kind of consent. It is time to leave this remnant of the colonial past behind.

Selected blog posts

220105_Misereor-PETA_Gold_Lim_Fairpicture-031
BLOG

March 2022 - Jörg Arnold

Pictures are more than illustrations

Images are powerful, and those who communicate with them bear a special responsibility. It is important that communicating organizations handle images and the corresponding context and metadata with care.

210318_TdH_Schweiz,_Mozambique_Fairpicture_follow-up_014
BLOG

October 2022 - Jörg Arnold

Visual Communication on a Tight Budget

Why do so many communication, marketing and fundraising managers struggle to find budget for photography and video production, and why do we need to solve this?

'Agarrando_Pueblo'_or_Vampires_of_Misery_(1977),_by_Luis_Ospina_and_Carlos_Mayolo_1
BLOG

April 2023 - Jaìr F. Coll

How to talk about consent and Misery Porn?

Misery Porn still persists today in visual storytelling, reducing people to their condition of misery and stripping them of their humanity.

Stay up to date

Get our monthly newsletter

Fairpicture is moving fast. Make sure you don't miss out on the newest news. Join our email newsletter and connect with us on LinkedIn and Instagram.

After signing up for the newsletter, you will also receive occasional emails about events and offers from Fairpicture. You may opt out any time. Here’s our privacy policy.